5 Things to Consider Before Buying a Business With Customer Concentration

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Imagine finding a business generating $600,000 in annual operating earnings. It’s growing, has an established customer base, and appears attractively priced relative to its profitability.

Then you discover that one customer accounts for 65% of revenue.

Would you walk away?

It’s an understandable reaction. Losing that customer could devastate the business. But rejecting every acquisition with significant customer concentration could also mean overlooking an opportunity that other buyers are unwilling to pursue.

I’ve written before about identifying and managing customer concentration. It’s a risk I’ve personally experienced as a business owner, including the uncomfortable leverage a major customer can exercise over a smaller company.

But there’s another question worth exploring: When does customer concentration represent a risk worth buying?

The answer depends on more than the percentage of revenue at stake. It depends on the earnings exposed, the durability of those earnings, what you’re paying for them, and whether you have a credible path to improving the business.

 

1. Customer concentration should affect what you’re willing to pay

A business with one customer generating 65% of revenue is fundamentally different from a business with 65 customers generating 1% each.

Even if their earnings are identical today, the reliability of those earnings is not.

Research supports the importance of this distinction.

A 2021 study published in the Journal of Corporate Finance found that acquirers of businesses with concentrated customer bases experienced weaker stock-market returns and long-term operating performance.

A separate study published in the Journal of Business Finance & Accounting found that customer-concentrated acquisition targets attracted fewer bids and that buyers were more likely to offer stock rather than cash.

These studies examine larger, publicly traded transactions, so we shouldn’t assume their findings translate directly into specific valuation discounts for Main Street businesses. But they reinforce an important principle: buyers recognize concentration as an investment risk, not merely an operational inconvenience.

That risk should influence valuation.

Suppose two businesses each generate $600,000 in earnings. One has diversified revenue; the other depends heavily on a single account.

Paying the same multiple for both assumes those earnings have comparable durability.

They may not.

But simply negotiating a lower multiple isn’t enough. Before deciding what discount is appropriate, you need to understand what you’re actually exposed to.

 

2. Underwrite the earnings you could lose, not just the revenue

Let’s return to our hypothetical business.

Assume it generates $2 million in annual revenue and $600,000 in operating earnings, before acquisition financing costs.

One customer represents 65% of sales, or $1.3 million.

Now suppose that customer disappears.

It’s tempting to assume earnings will decline by 65%, too. But revenue concentration and profit concentration aren’t necessarily the same thing.

Some costs disappear when sales disappear. Others don’t.

Let’s assume the lost customer generated a 40% contribution margin after directly variable costs. That means the relationship contributed approximately $520,000 annually toward covering fixed expenses and generating profit.

If the business cannot reduce its remaining costs, losing that customer could take annual operating earnings from $600,000 to just $80,000.

 

 

That’s an approximately 87% reduction in earnings from losing 65% of revenue.

Now consider the acquisition price.

At three times earnings, the buyer might pay $1.8 million. At two times earnings, the price falls to $1.2 million.

The second price is substantially cheaper. But if the customer leaves and earnings fall to $80,000, even the discounted acquisition may become financially untenable.

And that’s before considering debt service.

A lower purchase multiple doesn’t necessarily make a concentrated business safe. It only reduces what you paid to assume the risk.

The more important question is whether the remaining business can survive the downside.

 

3. Don’t pay the seller for growth you haven’t created

Here’s where concentration can become interesting for an acquisition entrepreneur.

A business with one dominant customer might have neglected its broader sales operation. Perhaps the seller has spent years servicing a large account rather than developing new relationships.

A new owner could see an opportunity to build a sales team, expand distribution, or win additional accounts.

That’s a legitimate acquisition thesis.

But it’s important to distinguish between what the seller has already built and what you believe you can build next.

Suppose you think you can reduce the largest customer’s share of revenue from 65% to 35% by growing the rest of the business.

 

 

That could substantially improve the company’s resilience and eventual resale value.

But those additional customers don’t exist yet.

You’ll have to find them, win their business, deliver successfully, and retain them. That requires execution, investment, and time.

The seller should generally be compensated for the earnings the business produces today, not the value you hope to create through your own work tomorrow.

This is one of the fundamental distinctions in acquisition entrepreneurship.

You want to identify opportunities where your capabilities can increase the value of an existing business. But if you pay upfront for all the improvements you plan to make, you’re giving away much of the upside you’re taking the risk to create.

Concentration can represent an opportunity to build value. It shouldn’t become an excuse to overpay for potential.

 

4. Can the transaction reflect the customer risk?

Price isn’t the only variable.

When a large portion of the acquisition’s value depends on retaining one relationship, buyers can sometimes negotiate terms that account for that uncertainty.

For example, part of the purchase price might be contingent on the customer remaining with the business or generating an agreed level of revenue after closing.

That approach can help bridge a disagreement between a seller who believes the relationship is secure and a buyer who is less certain.

But contingent payments aren’t a magic solution.

They introduce questions about:

  • Measurement: How will customer retention or revenue performance be calculated?
  • Control: Who manages the customer relationship after closing?
  • Operations: What happens if the buyer changes how the business operates?
  • Financing: Is the arrangement compatible with the buyer’s acquisition financing?

 

Sellers also have legitimate reasons to resist putting their proceeds at risk based on decisions made after they’ve relinquished control.

The objective isn’t to transfer every possible risk to the seller.

It’s to find a structure that reflects the uncertainty both parties are being asked to accept.

And sometimes the seller simply won’t agree.

That’s when the buyer has to decide whether the economics still work without those protections.

 

5. Know the difference between an opportunity and a gamble

A concentrated business can be attractive when the relationship is durable, the customer has meaningful reasons to stay, and the buyer has a credible plan to expand beyond it.

But the decision becomes much harder when concentration is increasing, a major contract renewal is approaching, or the remaining business couldn’t support its obligations if the relationship ended.

There’s also an important difference between having a plan to diversify and needing that plan to succeed immediately.

If the acquisition only works financially after you win several new customers, you’re not buying a business that supports your investment thesis today. You’re betting that your future execution will rescue it.

That’s a very different proposition.

I don’t believe acquisition entrepreneurs should avoid every business with concentrated revenue. Some risks are manageable, and some may create opportunities precisely because other buyers are unwilling to investigate them.

But I would never evaluate concentration in isolation.

I’d want to know:

  • The downside: What happens if the major customer leaves?
  • The price: Does the purchase price compensate me for that possibility?
  • My advantage: What specific capabilities do I bring to improving the business?

 

The goal isn’t to buy a business without risk. It’s to understand which risks you’re being paid to take and which ones could cost you the entire investment.

Picture of Walker Deibel

Walker Deibel

Walker Deibel is an entrepreneur and advisor. He is the author of Buy Then Build: How Acquisition Entrepreneurs Outsmart the Startup Game and Creator of Acquisition Lab.

Free Newsletter

Outsmart the Startup Game

Join 50,000+ entrepreneurs and investors getting proven private market insights straight to their inbox:

No spam. Ever.

Free Newsletter

Outsmart the Startup Game

Join 50,000+ entrepreneurs and investors getting proven private market insights straight to their inbox:

No spam. Ever.